Zarephath

"Nothing can be redeemed unless it is embraced." -- St. Ambrose
"The world is a book, and those who do not travel read only one page." -- Augustine

My Photo
Name:
Location: Chicago, United States

Monday, April 22, 2013

Quantum Mechanics and The Trinity

When Christians speak of The Trinity, as they have for at least 1900 years, we are simply using a label for the following set of statements:

1. God the Father is God.
2. Jesus Christ is God.
3. The Holy Spirit is God.
4. There is one God.

How do we reconcile these statements? By saying that God consists of three persons - that is, in His essence (ousia) and divinity He is one , but in personhood (hypostaseis) He is three. It is easy to see why this is not irrational by expressing these concepts mathematically.

If God is one god and three gods, then:

1 God = 3 Gods
therefore,
1 = 3.

If God is one person and three persons, then:

1 Person = 3 Persons
therefore,
1 = 3.

But in the Trinity,

1 God = 3 Persons.


(And these 3 persons are in eternal relationship with each other, such that God has always lived in a community of perfect love).

This is a concept that is beyond my intellect or imagination. It is an inexhaustible mystery. It defies all categories of human thought. But it is not irrational. It is fully within the bounds of logic and reason.

For years, scientists debated as to whether the electron was a particle or a wave. (Light was also the subject of the same argument). In 1897, J.J. Thomson measured the charge/mass ratio of the electron, thus establishing that it was a particle and earning himself a Nobel Prize in 1906. His son, George, won the Nobel Prize in 1937 for measuring the wavelength of electrons, thus proving that they were waves, which must have made for some awkward conversations at family gatherings. So which is it?

Both. In 1926, Erwin Schrödinger used Louis de Broglie's concept of wave-particle duality to formulate a mathematical equation explaining how anything could simultaneously be a wave and a particle, earning himself a Noble prize and setting off unending speculation about his cat. This result, with it's probabilistic implications (as in the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle), was profoundly unsettling to some. Albert Einstein won the Nobel Prize (in part) for his explanation of the photoelectric effect, which established the particle nature of light and confirmed the basic hypothesis of quantum mechanics. Yet these conclusions led him to angrily respond, "God does not play dice with the universe!"

It's always amusing when scientists - or theologians - tell God what He can and cannot do.

Nevertheless, despite its rigorous formulation and experimental verification, this fundamental law of quantum mechanics is difficult to picture. It's one thing to explain mathematically, via a "probability wavefunction," how something can simultaneously be at one point and also be sort-of-everywhere and sort-of-nowhere. It's another thing to attempt to explain this to someone in terms from everyday life that would make one bit of sense. They would probably see it as a contradiction, when in reality it is simply a little - or perhaps a lot - beyond the sort of thing we encounter in a normal day.

I observed this blurring of distinction, between that which is irrational and that which is difficult to understand, on multiple occasions when interacting with atheists (or with Muslims, in the case of the Trinity). But given the upheavals in physics over the past century, why do we continue to make this mistake in our understanding of the natural world - or of God?

Perhaps it's because we think we are smarter than we are. We think that surely, with our education and our civilization and our iPhones, we are advanced enough to understand everything - if only God would quit talking in riddles. We never stopped to consider that any complete answers might be far beyond our comprehension.

The oldest book of the Bible is an extended exploration of senseless suffering which, in some ways, raises more questions than it answers. We see Job, a righteous man, refusing to believe the logically simple explanations of his friends because they don't fit who he knows himself - or God - to be. He persistently demands his day in court with God. When God finally shows up, the tables are suddenly turned: "Brace yourself like a man! I will question you, and you will answer me!" God then proceeds to show Job just how little he (or anyone of us) actually knows. It's as if God is saying, "If I tried to explain to you what is really going on, it would be like trying to explain the General Theory of Relativity to a kindergartener."

That's why Jesus tells us to receive the Kingdom like little children. Children know that they don't understand everything, that's it's okay to trust someone wiser than yourself, and that the world is often a mysteriously wonderful place. God isn't asking us to believe that 3 = 1 or to reject reason; rather, He is asking us to accept the fact that if we can't even comprehend the electron, we will never be able to wrap our minds around the fullness of His being.

Labels: ,

Monday, February 11, 2013

The Rocks Don't Lie / David R. Montgomery (Norton, 2012)

This book is primarily a refutation of the "flood geology" underlying young-earth creationism. I abandoned the young-earth view years ago as contradicting not only science but the clearest reading of the Bible (particularly Genesis 1:1-2). Most scientists would dismiss it as ridiculous. But Montgomery first takes young-earth claims seriously, and then solidly refutes them. By the time he is done, you realize just how fanciful it is to believe that the entire earth was reshaped by a global flood.

As a chemical engineer, I have always viewed geology with suspicion. Unlike chemistry or physics, you couldn't easily do experiments to verify theories. All we have are the existing rocks, and two people could look at the same thing yet come to different conclusions, with no easy way of settling the matter. Montgomery's lucid explanations did elevate my opinion of geology, demonstrating just how often we can see geologic history spelled out in rock formations.

The narrative structure makes the book compelling. Non-scientists forget that science is a human endeavor, carried out with human motivations and failings and sometimes by colorful personalities. And it is an ongoing quest for knowledge, a process by which we strive towards the truth, and not merely a settled body of facts. If a class were advertised on "The History of Geology," enrollment would probably be poor. But Montgomery makes it a fascinating story, enriched by his continued surprise at the rich and complex interplay between Christian faith and what was once termed natural philosophy. He makes it clear that the story he found was not what he expected, and runs counter to the revisionist narrative of "warfare between science and religion." It might have been simpler to stick to that narrative, but he instead tells it like it was.

The weakest link is the 9th chapter, "Recycled Tales," in which Montgomery tries to track down the origin of flood stories (and explain why some cultures have them and some don't). But when it comes to Noah's Flood, he trips over poor knowledge of the Bible: assuming that the Pentateuch was written 1000 years after Moses (based upon ideas in vogue in the 19th century), imagining contradictions where there are none, and deciding that flood stories with obvious political or social agendas are more trustworthy than the only one with no clear agenda (other than providing an intellectual foundation for human flourishing and freedom). Here is it is Montgomery who is 150 years behind modern scholarship, stuck in the old mode of "higher criticism." Higher criticism is driven by a three-fold presumption of guilt, that: 1) no book of the Bible could possibly have been written by the author to whom is it attributed; 2) whoever did write it must have been hopelessly biased, ignorant, or stupid; and 3) the texts we have today must have been so altered that there is no way we can know what was originally written by whoever it was that wrote it. The errors in this chapter may cause some readers to question other parts of the book, which would be truly unfortunate.

The final chapter, "The Nature of Faith," was poorly titled. It's fine if read as an attempt to put a personal touch on the questions examined throughout the book. It does make a nice epilogue to share how the researching of a book affected your own beliefs. But if Montgomery truly intends to lecture us on the nature of faith, he has much learning to do.

Additionally, these two chapters weaken the overall argument. It's as if Montgomery begins by saying, "Biblical interpretation and geology need not conflict," but then declares, "The Bible is bunk anyways" - in which case, who cares whether or not these two disciplines can be reconciled? Of course, if Montgomery doesn't find the Bible believable, he shouldn't pretend otherwise, but in that case he would have been wiser to skirt the question and stick to geology. He implies that while understanding the Bible is a hopeless endeavor, reading the rocks is simple and straightforward. But if rocks could interpret themselves, he (and other geologists) wouldn't have a job. It is possible to misread both the record of the rocks and the written record of God's activity, but it is also possible to progress in our understanding of either.

On the whole, The Rocks Don't Lie is an excellent overview of how the science of geology developed, and a surprisingly generous and open-minded recounting of its historical interaction with Christianity. Even the chapter recounting a visit to the infamous Creation Museum ends with a focus on how evangelical Christians instead strove to integrate the facts of geology with good Biblical interpretation!

Those wishing to understand Genesis better, or the overall relationship between science and faith, should see the work of Davis Young and Hugh Ross. The latter demonstrates how the most straightforward and literal reading of Genesis 1 actually concurs with everything modern science has told us from astronomy, biology and geology.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Against Lysenkoism - or Group-Think?

I sent this letter to Books & Culture after a reviewer referred to climate-change skepticism as "Lysenkoism."

Bill McKibben's review of David Archer's The Global Carbon Cycle suffers from three errors that have plagued climate-change advocacy since the advent of the debate. First is his emphasis on "consensus" - science is not done by consensus, but by experimental evidence and logical proof. The "scientific consensus" has often been proven wrong, by experimentation, on significant questions. Second is the trust in computer models simply because they fit the past data. Given any set of data points in any shape or pattern, I can construct a curve through those points and then describe it with an equation. That does not mean that I actually understand the system in question! The only worthwhile test of a model is it's ability to predict future results, and not one climate model has succeeded in accurately predicting the weather. Third is the omission of stubborn facts, such as: the vast majority of the rise in global temperatures occurred before 1945, yet the vast majority of the rise in atmospheric CO2 occurred after 1945. Climate-change believers ought to have either the courage to address such facts, or the humility to admit that they don't fully understand the CO2/temperature relationship.

Labels: ,

Saturday, July 09, 2011

RE: Search for the Historical Adam

Here's the letter I wrote to Christianity Today in response to their recent cover article, "The Search For the Historical Adam" -

Dear Editors,


I was surprised that your cover story failed to mention a single one of the DNA studies from the past 3 decades on human origins. A study of mitochondrial DNA, published in 1987, concluded that all human beings alive today are descended from a single woman, dubbed "Mitochondrial Eve." Numerous molecular anthropology studies since then, reported in such journals as Science and Nature, have corroborated these findings, similarly concluding that humanity originated from [at most] a very small population in a single location. The scientists you quoted made it sound as if the historicity of Adam and Eve is in direct conflict with science, but the published data indicate the opposite.
Here is the response I received:

An earlier draft of the story actually did have a brief section on that discussion, but we cut it both for space and because there was too much he-said/he-said back and forth in the article as it was. 

For what it's worth, here's what Biologos says about Mitochondrial Eve: http://biologos.org/questions/the-mitochondrial-eve I'm not sending it along as an endorsement, but just as an indication of why we didn't go deeply into the mitochondrial-Eve/y-chromosome-Adam discussion.

Thanks for reading, and thanks for writing!


Ted Olsen
Managing Editor, News & Online Journalism
Christianity Today

With all due respect, shouldn't the readers have been given the opportunity to hear both sides of this  "he-said, she-said" argument? I realize that CT is not a science magazine, and the primary point of the story was to explore the theological implications of the subject, but it was misleading to imply that the scientific debate was over. (Who Was Adam by Hugh Ross and Fazale Rana presents a thorough and convincing case for the pro-historical position; perhaps someday the theistic evolutionists will respond in kind).  In fact, the entire story quotes only a single scientific fact - the similarity between human and chimpanzee DNA - and otherwise only quotes the opinions of scientists which, although worthy of serious consideration, should not be confused with science itself.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, July 07, 2009

The Repentance of a Young-Earth Creationist

“ ‘Neanderthal Man’ was simply a human who walked bent over because he had arthritis. …

There are few, if any, reliable clocks that give the age of the earth to be much older than 10,000 years. …

It is estimated that NASA spent almost $1 billion to figure out how to keep the lunar lander from sinking into the vast amounts of moon dust falsely predicted if the moon were a billion years old.”

I made these claims as a university sophomore in my very first opinion column in the Kansas State Collegian, published on Friday, August 27, 1999.

I was wrong.

I knew at least some of these claims to be false by the spring of 2000; others, I learned of only more recently. How I came to this realization – and, to a lesser extent, why it has taken me so long to speak out – is the subject of this post. The shortest possible summary is found in Proverbs 18:17, “The first to present his case seems right, until another comes forward and questions him.”

At the time that I wrote my column, I was familiar with 3 views of origins: naturalistic evolution, theistic evolution, and young-earth creationism. I easily rejected the first because it utterly excluded God from the creation process and because I could not see how Darwinian mechanims could produce life in all its diversity. Theistic evolution seemed to me like a half-baked idea, merely naturalistic evolution with a veneer of God painted over it, resulting in a poorly-formulated theory that failed to fit either Darwin or Genesis. Although I have since encountered much better formulations of it, the sense of my original objections remains. The young-earth creationist (YEC) viewpoint was trumpeted by every Christian organization I was familiar with, it was the only one I encountered in our local Christian bookstore, it seemed to be very faithful to the Bible, and the science sounded convincing enough.

But when I publicly jumped into the fray over the 1999 Kansas Science Standards – which eliminated Darwinism, the "Big Bang" Theory, and the age of the earth from the curriculum – I quickly became aware of some glaring deficiencies in my view. Though I still had much to learn, I could generally hold my own when it came to biology – if nothing else, I could pick apart most arguments and show that there was, at best, reasonable doubt for claims that natural selection plus random mutation could generate completely new types of organisms. But I knew virtually nothing of astronomy, geology, or anthropology. In exchanges with professors at both Kansas State University and the University of Kansas over these subjects, I quickly proved myself to be an irritating ignoramus. And this began to torment me.

I had taken a public stand on something I could not fully defend. I was way out of my depth. And try as I might, I could not get around the fact that we could see stars that were hundreds of millions of light years away – meaning the universe had to be at least that old for their light to reach us. Psalm 19:1 exuberantly proclaims, “The heavens declare the glory of God!” When I looked up at the night sky in Kansas, dotted with hundreds of stars, I couldn’t rejoice – I just felt bewildered.

The following semester, two things happened which would define my view of origins for the rest of my life. The first was that I completed BIOL 198, Principles of Biology and was utterly unimpressed with the arguments used to sell Darwinism to us. Most proved nothing more than micro-evolution (variations within a species, possibly producing a new but highly-related species with no new features); others were illustrations completely unrelated to actual processes in nature, in which the deck was stacked artificially to make it appear as if Darwinism “worked.” The creation-evolution debate had nearly erupted into an all-out war, and these were the best evidences they had? From that point on, I never took Darwinism seriously as a theory of origins.

The second was that I picked up a book at the local Christian bookstore, which in less than 200 pages refuted everything I had ever read about the age of the Earth and the correct interpretation of Genesis 1. That book was Creation and Time, by Dr. Hugh Ross, an astrophysicist, a Christian, and the founder of Reasons To Believe. It was the first time I had ever heard a fair presentation of the old-earth creationist viewpoint. I had never even considered it before. I didn’t want Hugh Ross to be right, not for any noble reason but simply because I didn’t want to wrong. But as I went back and forth between all the YEC resources I could find, and Dr. Ross’ little book, I found myself unable to resist his clear arguments and evidence from both nature and Scripture. The YECs all boasted about their fidelity to Scripture, but Dr. Ross was the first person I had ever encountered who actually took Genesis 1:1 and 1:2 literally. His entire exposition of the text made more sense than anything I had ever read in YEC material, and it fit better with the rest of the Bible as well. And his scientific explanations not only showed the bankruptcy of the YEC arguments – some of which bordered on dishonesty – they also allowed me to rejoice in the discoveries which were being made about God’s world, instead of constantly fearing them. Nevertheless, I initially embraced the the old-earth view as “the most dejected convert” (as C.S. Lewis describes his conversion from atheism to theism).

But I said nothing publicly. Having been wrong once, I was afraid of speaking too soon. I was at least 99% sure I had been wrong, but what if I really hadn’t been? And although I had twice apologized for erroneous statements in opinion columns, writing an entire column repudiating my former view seemed like too bitter a pill to swallow, not to mention that I didn’t know how to fill my allotted space with it. So I said nothing, gave up my platform at the end of the school year, and returned to normal life as a student and aspiring engineer.

The summer between my undergraduate and graduate educations, Answers In Genesis conducted a Vacation Bible School at my home church. I’m not sure how much the children learned about Jesus, but for an entire week they heard young-earth theories about dinosaurs and were taught that science couldn’t be trusted. The final night, the leader spoke to all the adults for a few hours, trying to convince us of the worthlessness of science and our obligation to believe in a young earth; at one point, he actually told us that if we rejected his views, we were denying that Jesus died for our sins! It was a proposterous twisting of God’s Word. I was offended and disgusted, but I lacked the courage to challenge him to his face.

Over the years, I kept studying and learning. I took the few opportunities I had to educate others, sent an email of apology to two Christian professors at K-State towards whom I had been disrespectful, and in graduate school co-founded a group to study the interface of science and Christianity. But I always regretted not publicly repenting for my error. Although I had “acted in ignorance” (Acts 3:17), my confidence was actually arrogance, and in so doing I had brought disrepute to the name of Jesus.

Today, I know that:

  • the “Big Bang” Theory is in fact a compelling confirmation of the Bible that has brought many physicists to faith
  • both the Earth and the Universe can be accurately measured as billions of years old
  • NASA was never very concerned about moon dust (as the YEC group Answers In Genesis now admits)
  • the speed of light has not changed but is in fact one of the key fundamental constants which must be finely-tuned in order for life to exist,
  • Neanderthals are competely unrelated to human beings
  • the Flood was quite likely a local (i.e. Middle-Eastern) event
  • the death of animals has nothing to do with human sin
  • the seventh day – the day of God’s rest – is still on-going today.

I now know that Christians have nothing to fear from scientific discoveries or inquisitive Biblical study. I praise God for His grace in gently leading me to the truth, and it is my prayer that others would follow in this pursuit. At the very least, all Christians ought to keep an open mind and a humble posture until they have listened to both sides of the debate, before rejecting out-of-hand the view held by nearly all Christians who actually do science for a living. As Proverbs 18:13 states, “He who answers before listening – that is his folly and shame.”

Labels: ,